Are Fluorescent Garage Lights Right For You? (Pros and Cons)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Choosing the right lighting for your garage is more important than you might think, and fluorescent lights are a popular option.

But are they right for you?

This article will cover what you need to know about fluorescent garage lights, from environmental concerns to practical issues.

As someone who has dealt with the ups and downs of various lighting options in a garage setting, I can share firsthand the pros and cons of fluorescent lights.

Whether you’re a DIY enthusiast, a homeowner looking for cost-effective solutions, or just curious about your lighting options, this guide will provide valuable insights.

We’ll start by addressing some of the main drawbacks of fluorescent lighting, such as the presence of mercury, which poses health and environmental risks, and the annoying flickering and humming noises these lights can make.

Then, we’ll discuss their temperature sensitivity and how it affects their performance, especially in colder environments.

We’ll also compare fluorescent garage lights with other lighting options like LED, halogen, and incandescent bulbs.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of their energy efficiency, brightness, color temperature, lifespan, and cost.

Let’s get started. 

Fluorescent tubes

Fluorescent Lighting: The Bad

Fluorescent lights are a popular lighting option for your garage. They’re cost-effective and have been around for ages, but like anything, they have downsides.

Let’s dive into some drawbacks of using fluorescent garage lighting.

Mercury Content

Fluorescent lamps contain a small amount of mercury, which is a toxic substance. If a lamp breaks or is improperly disposed, it poses a health and environmental hazard.

I remember one time when a fluorescent tube in my garage accidentally shattered. Since mercury can cause neurological damage, respiratory problems, or skin irritation, the cleanup was nerve-wracking.

Environmental contamination is another issue.

If mercury is released into the environment, it can pollute soil, water, and air, causing broader ecological problems.

To safely handle and dispose of fluorescent bulbs, always use gloves, ensure the area is well-ventilated, carefully seal any broken pieces, and take them to a designated recycling facility.

Flickering & Humming

Do you know that annoying buzz or flicker when you switch fluorescent lights on or dim them?

That’s a common issue, especially as the bulbs age.

This flickering and humming aren’t just irritating; they can also be quite stressful if you spend a lot of time in your garage.

From a performance standpoint, this flickering and humming can reduce the light output, alter the color, and shorten the lamps’ lifespans. If you’re using dimmers, ensure they’re compatible with your fluorescent garage lights.

Startup Delay & Cold Sensitivity

Fluorescent lamps are notorious for their startup delay and sensitivity to cold temperatures.

This can be inconvenient and even unsafe, especially if you need immediate, adequate illumination, like when working on a project or navigating around tools and equipment.

Energy efficiency and durability are also impacted by these delays and sensitivities since fluorescent lamps tend to consume more power and have a shorter lifespan in colder conditions.

To minimize these issues, you can use instant-start or rapid-start lamps.

Additionally, installing heaters or insulation in your garage can help maintain a temperature more conducive to the efficient operation of fluorescent garage lighting.


Fluorescent Lighting: The Good

After discussing the drawbacks, let’s shift gears and talk about the advantages of using fluorescent lighting in your garage.

Despite some limitations, fluorescent lights offer several benefits that can make them a great choice for many homeowners.

Energy Efficiency & Cost Savings

Fluorescent lamps are very energy efficient. They can produce the same amount of light, or lumens, using significantly less energy than traditional incandescent lamps, which translates into substantial energy consumption and cost savings.

In fact, fluorescent lamps can save between 75% to 80% of energy for the same light output. That’s not just good for your wallet. It’s also great for the planet.

Plus, fluorescent bulbs can last up to ten times longer than incandescent lamps, which means less frequent replacements and less maintenance hassle.

Better Light Diffusion & Distribution

Another advantage of fluorescent lamps is their ability to diffuse light more effectively.

They’re typically larger than incandescent bulbs, which allows for better light distribution throughout the garage. This results in more uniform and consistent lighting, minimizing glare and uneven brightness spots.

Additionally, fluorescent lamps offer a variety of color temperatures and hues.

Depending on the type and coating of the lamp, you can choose lighting that suits your specific needs.

Less Heat Emission & Environmental Impact

Since fluorescent lamps are more energy efficient, they operate at a lower temperature than incandescent bulbs. This means a more comfortable environment in your garage, especially during the hot summer months.

Less heat also means less need for air conditioning or ventilation, saving energy and costs.

From an environmental standpoint, by consuming less electricity and having a longer lifespan, these lamps contribute to lower greenhouse gas emissions and a reduced carbon footprint.


How Do Fluorescent Garage Lights Compare with Other Types of Lighting?

When lighting your garage, you have several options: fluorescent, LED, halogen, and incandescent.

Let’s see how fluorescent compares to these alternatives.

Energy Efficiency: Energy efficiency is a big deal in garage lighting. Fluorescent lights already set a high bar by using about 75% less energy and lasting up to 10 times longer than traditional incandescent bulbs.

However, LED lights win, here. They use up to 90% less energy and can last up to 25 times longer than incandescent bulbs.

In the long run, LED lights are more cost-effective, reducing electricity bills and replacement costs. Plus, they’re environmentally friendlier, as they don’t contain mercury, a concern with fluorescent garage lights.

Brightness: In terms of brightness, LED lights are more efficient than fluorescents. They produce more lumens per watt.

For example, a 150-watt LED fixture can generate a whopping 24,000 lumens, while a typical T8 fluorescent bulb produces about 3,100 lumens using 32 watts.

This difference is noticeable when working on detailed projects in your garage.

Color Temperature & CRI: Color temperature and Color Rendering Index (CRI) are crucial for the quality of light.

Fluorescent lights usually range between 3000K and 4100K, with 5000K available but less common. Their CRI is lower, around 60 to 70, which can distort colors.

On the other hand, LED lights offer a wider range of color temperatures, ranging from 2700K to 5000K. More importantly, their CRI is 80 or higher, meaning they display colors more accurately and vividly.

This can make a huge difference when you’re trying to match paint colors or need to see the true color of something you’re working on.

Lifespan: LEDs typically have a longer lifespan as well.

While fluorescents last between 6,000 to 15,000 hours, with the best reaching 35,000 hours, LEDs have a minimum rating of 50,000 hours, up to 200,000 hours for specialty products.

This means LEDs can outlast fluorescents by 2.5 times or more.

Plus, LEDs maintain their light quality longer, whereas fluorescent lights experience luminous decay, losing brightness and color accuracy over time.

Cost: LEDs have a higher upfront cost than fluorescents but are more economical over time. LEDs’ longer lifespan and energy savings mean fewer replacements and lower electricity bills.

For example, a 60-watt equivalent LED bulb may cost around $4, compared to $2 for a comparable CFL bulb. Still, the LED lasts much longer, reducing overall costs over a 10-year period.

Environmental Impact: Environmentally, LEDs have a smaller carbon footprint than conventional lights, generating less CO2 and saving natural resources. They are more efficient, hence reducing greenhouse gas emissions significantly.

For example, a 60-watt equivalent LED bulb uses only 9 watts of power compared to 13 watts for a similar CFL bulb.

In the end, while fluorescent lights are a good option for garage lighting, offering energy efficiency and cost savings over incandescent bulbs, LEDs outshine them in almost every aspect.

From energy savings to environmental impact, LEDs provide a more sustainable and efficient lighting solution for your garage.


Wrapping It Up

So, we’ve looked at the ins and outs of fluorescent garage lighting, weighing its pros and cons and comparing it with other lighting options like LED, halogen, and incandescent.

We discovered that while fluorescent lights offer energy efficiency and cost savings compared to incandescent bulbs, they have drawbacks, like mercury and issues with flickering and cold sensitivity.

On the flip side, they provide better light diffusion and have a lesser environmental impact than their incandescent counterparts.

Compared to other types of lighting, like LEDs, fluorescents hold up reasonably well but don’t match LED options in terms of efficiency, lifespan, and eco-friendliness. LEDs emerge as a more energy-efficient, brighter, and longer-lasting solution, albeit at a higher initial cost.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Follow us on social media!

Photo of author

Tim Wells

Tim Wells, the founder of Garage Transformed, has been featured in dozens of home renovation publications, including BobVila.com, Home Stratosphere, House Digest, Livingetc, and SFGate. Since 2018, he has helped over two million people transform their everyday garages into something they can be proud of. He lives in Central Florida with his wife and bulldog.

Leave a Comment