Garage Door Roller Replacement: Easy Fix for Noisy Garage Doors

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Follow us on social media!

If your garage door grinds as it shudders up and down the track, you should consider replacing the rollers.

Plastic garage door rollers come standard with many new homes. They’re even installed by many aftermarket companies as a cost-saving measure. They’re only meant to last as long as your warranty and often fail soon after it expires.

Here are my plastic garage door rollers after only one year.

worn out plastic garage door rollers

Every time the door opened or closed, the side of the track would shave some of the rollers off. Once it was thin enough, chunks started falling off, causing the wheel to bounce as it moved up and down the track.

It sounded like the door wouldn’t open, so I replaced the rollers.

Garage door roller replacement is one of the easiest (and cheapest) ways to upgrade your garage door.

It doesn’t matter whether you have steel rollers that rattle up and down the track or old plastic rollers that look like shredded cheese. You can make your door feel better than new for less than dinner at McDonald’s.

How Often Should Garage Door Rollers Be Replaced?

Depending on what material your rollers are made of, they could last a lifetime or as little as one year.

In general, their lifespan will increase as you move up from plastic to steel to nylon rollers.

Plastic rollers will usually only last one to two years before needing to be replaced. Steel rollers are more durable and often rated for 10,000 to 12,000 cycles. That’s about eight years if you open and close the door four times every day.

I recommend using a nylon garage door roller like the DURA-LIFT Ultra-Life MAX roller. They have a lifetime guarantee and are quieter than steel rollers.

They have a sealed bearing to keep the dust and dirt out surrounding a heavy, 14-gauge steel stem for higher load ratings.

They’re rated for a staggering 125,000 cycles, so you’d need to open and close your garage door ten times daily for over forty years to hit that!

Garage Door Rollers: Nylon vs. Steel vs. Plastic

The first question you must ask is what you want to gain from replacing your garage door rollers? Do you want durability? Noise reduction?

That decision will drive what kind of garage door rollers you should buy.

Three materials are commonly used for garage door rollers: plastic, steel, and nylon.

Plastic rollers are found in some of the cheaper new construction builds or wherever the contractors want to save money. They’re usually black in color and have no need for lubrication. They’re only designed to be temporary until you get something more durable.

Steel rollers are much more durable and require regular lubrication. If well maintained, they’ll essentially last forever. There’s one other drawback: they’re loud.

A clunky steel roller running along a steel track is a recipe for noise.

Nylon rollers are rarely included with new construction, almost always added after the fact. Occasionally, if you upgrade your garage door, the installer will give you the option of adding nylon rollers.

If you’re given that option, take it. When comparing nylon garage door rollers vs steel, nylon is quieter than steel rollers and more durable than plastic rollers.

In most cases, nylon garage door rollers are the best choice, but there are still other factors you need to consider.

Nylon garage door rollers

Garage Door Roller Replacement Costs

That’s the big question, right? How much is it going to cost to replace garage door rollers?

This probably won’t come as a shock, but it depends on how big your garage door is.

If you’ve got a seven-foot-tall garage door, you’ll typically have ten rollers for the entire door. An eight-foot-tall garage door will add another two rollers for a total of twelve.

At one of the big box stores like Lowe’s or Home Depot, a pair of plastic or steel garage door rollers can run you around $5 – between $25 – $30 for a complete set.

Instead, I recommend springing for the Dura-Lift nylon rollers, which are higher quality, quieter than the steel rollers, and cheaper too.

DURA-LIFT Ultra-Life MAX Nylon Garage Door Roller
  • Reduces garage door noise by at least 75% compared to standard steel rollers
  • 6200ZZ Bearing rated for 200,000 door open and close cycles
  • Front and back sealed caps prevents dust & grime from penetrating roller
  • Lubrication groove on roller to disperse lubrication over extended period
  • 100% Lifetime Guarantee
Check Latest Price
This site contains product affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you purchase after clicking on one of these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How To Replace Garage Door Rollers Yourself

Safety Disclaimer: Replacing the bottom roller on a garage door can be extremely dangerous when done incorrectly. NEVER loosen the bolts that secure the bottom fixture to the garage door or remove the cable from the bottom fixture. Failure to adhere to these warnings may cause the door to cock, jamb, or fall, resulting in property damage and/or personal injury or death. Consider yourself warned!

Don't touch the red screws!

In all seriousness, garage doors are under A LOT of tension.

My door has a cable that runs down the side of the door attached to the bottom roller with some red screws. When the door is closed, the cable sounds like a bass guitar string if you pluck it.

So do yourself (and your loved ones) a favor and never unscrew the bottom roller bracket!

Before you get started, there are two safety precautions to take:

  • Unplug your garage door opener. It’s unlikely that the garage door will start up by itself, but we want to be as safe as possible.
  • Unhook the trolley from the garage door arm to move the door freely up and down.

Now that we’ve got that out of the way…

Let’s start with the easy ones first.

Do You Need To Bend The Track?

There are two schools of thought about replacing rollers: bend the track or unscrew the brackets.

The people who say to bend the track will say you need to do it anyway to tackle the bottom roller (more on that later). If you’re already doing it for one set of rollers, you might as well do it for all of them.

But the people who say to unscrew the brackets and just pop in new rollers will tell you this is more straightforward. It also saves you the trouble of popping each garage door section off the track.

It also saves some wear on the rollers when trying to squeeze them back on the track.

I fall into the second camp. For me, unscrewing the brackets was much simpler and only took a few minutes per roller.

How to Replace Upper Garage Door Rollers

Grab a socket wrench and unscrew the retaining bolts to the garage door rollers brackets. Again…DO NOT DO THIS FOR THE BOTTOM ROLLER.

Sorry to sound like a broken record, but it’s essential.

Once you’ve got the bracket off, the roller will slide right out of the track.

Easy right?

It’s good to inspect your garage door brackets for any damage, especially if you have an older garage door. I had a relatively new house, so mine was OK.

The old plastic roller just falls out, and the new one just slides into place.

Replace your garage door rollers

When you’re putting the new rollers into your garage door hinges, adding a little lubricant is good to help things run smoothly.

I like using WD-40 White Lithium Grease, which is garage-door safe. Just be sure not to use the normal red-cap WD-40.

WD-40 Specialist White Lithium Grease Spray
  • Ideal for metal-to-metal applications that require heavy-duty lubrication and protection against rust and corrosion
  • Sprays on evenly as a liquid and sets dry for a thick, protective coating that won't run off. Safe from 0° F to 300° F for unbeatable protection
Check Latest Price
This site contains product affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you purchase after clicking on one of these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

After the roller is in and you’ve added a little lubricant, just screw the bracket back in and move on to the next roller.

How to Replace the Bottom Garage Door Roller

The safest way to replace the bottom roller is to bend the track so you can pop the bottom section out.

Don’t worry. It’s easier than it sounds and doesn’t damage the track itself.

You’ll first want to open the door completely to get full access to the track without the door getting in your way.

Pick a location on the track about elbow height to you to make it as comfortable as possible. Be sure to pick a spot in the middle of a section of the track as well.

Using some heavy plyers, pry the track slightly open for about two inches. You just want it loose enough to ease the roller wheel out but not enough so that you warp the track.

Manually lower the door so the roller’s wheel is right inside the track section you opened up. Using a long screwdriver, pry the door out of the track.

You’ll need to use leverage here, but be careful of the tension cable.

Once the door pops out of the track, the roller can slide out of the bracket.

The roller can slide out of the bracket once the door pops out of the track.

Add some white Lithium grease here to help the rollers spin smoothly.

Once the roller is in place, it’s time to pop the door panel back into the track.

This took a little finesse and a bit of brute force. You may need to use the long screwdriver again as a pry bar to help you.

Don't touch the red screws!

Once you pop the roller back into the track, ensure that the door moves along the track smoothly. If you’re satisfied that it’s working correctly, we can bend the track back into place.

Once you’re done, it’s worth taking a few minutes and lubricating your garage door track and hinges to keep them in great shape. See my recommendations for the best garage door lubricants here.

Wrapping It Up

If you had worn-out plastic rollers, then garage door roller replacement is one of the easiest ways to get my garage door functioning smoothly again. The door is quieter, the movement is smoother, and I expect the rollers to last at least ten years.

Now that you’ve replaced the rollers, it’s time to give the outside of your garage door some love and attention.

I recommend checking out my guide on How to Clean Your Garage Door because it’ll show you a quick and easy way to get your garage door looking like new again.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Follow us on social media!

Photo of author

Tim Wells

Tim Wells, the founder of Garage Transformed, has been featured in dozens of home renovation publications, including, Home Stratosphere, House Digest, Livingetc, and SFGate. Since 2018, he has helped over two million people transform their everyday garages into something they can be proud of. He lives in Central Florida with his wife and bulldog.

Leave a Comment